Convertible Note vs. SAFE: Key Differences Explained

Startup funding is a crucial aspect of business growth, and entrepreneurs must choose the right financing method when raising capital. Two popular investment instruments in the early-stage startup ecosystem are Convertible Notes and Simple Agreements for Future Equity (SAFE). While both options help startups secure funding without immediately setting a valuation, they have distinct structures, benefits, and risks. In this guide, we will explore the key differences between Convertible Notes and SAFE agreements, helping you determine which is the best fit for your startup.

What is a Convertible Note?

A Convertible Note is a short-term debt instrument that converts into equity at a later stage, typically during a future financing round. Startups issue Convertible Notes to investors as a form of loan that accrues interest and eventually converts into company shares based on predetermined terms.

Key Features of a Convertible Note

1. Debt Instrument – A Convertible Note is considered debt until it converts into equity.
2. Interest Rate – The note accrues interest, which increases the investment amount that converts into equity.
3. Maturity Date – Convertible Notes have a specified duration, after which they must convert into equity or be repaid.
4. Conversion Trigger – Conversion occurs when a startup raises a qualified financing round.
5. Valuation Cap & Discount – Investors receive a valuation cap or discount to compensate for early investment risk.

What is a SAFE Agreement?

A SAFE (Simple Agreement for Future Equity) is an investment contract that allows investors to provide capital to a startup in exchange for the right to receive equity in a future funding round. Unlike Convertible Notes, SAFE agreements are not debt instruments and do not have a maturity date or interest.

Key Features of a SAFE Agreement

1. Equity Instrument – SAFE agreements are not considered debt and do not have repayment obligations.
2. No Interest or Maturity Date – Investors do not earn interest, and there is no deadline for conversion.
3. Conversion Based on Future Rounds – SAFE investments convert into equity when a startup raises a future funding round.
4. Valuation Cap & Discount – Investors may receive a valuation cap or discount to secure favorable equity conversion terms.
5. Flexibility – SAFE agreements provide startups with fewer financial constraints compared to Convertible Notes.

Key Differences Between Convertible Notes and SAFE Agreements

When startups seek funding, they often choose between Convertible Notes and Simple Agreements for Future Equity (SAFE) to raise capital. While both are mechanisms for early-stage investment, they have distinct differences in structure, risk, and impact on both investors and startups. Below is a detailed comparison:

1.Debt vs. Equity

• Convertible Note: A convertible note is essentially a short-term debt instrument that is meant to be repaid or converted into equity in the future. Until conversion, it functions as a loan to the company, meaning the startup has a legal obligation to repay the investment amount under certain conditions.
• SAFE: A SAFE agreement, on the other hand, is not considered debt. Instead, it is a legal promise that allows an investor to purchase equity in the company at a future financing round, usually at a discounted price. Unlike convertible notes, there is no loan aspect, and startups do not owe repayment if conversion does not occur.

2. Interest Accrual

• Convertible Note: Since it is a loan, a convertible note comes with an interest rate that accrues over time. This means that, upon conversion into equity, the total investment amount increases to reflect the accumulated interest. The investor ultimately receives a greater stake in the company to compensate for the time value of money.
• SAFE: SAFEs do not carry any interest because they are not structured as loans. Investors simply agree to receive equity in the future without expecting any interest accumulation over time.

3. Maturity Date

• Convertible Note: Convertible notes come with a maturity date, which is a predetermined deadline by which the startup must either convert the note into equity or repay the investor. If conversion does not happen by the maturity date, investors may have the right to demand repayment, which can create financial pressure on the startup.
• SAFE: Unlike convertible notes, SAFE agreements do not have a maturity date. This means there is no set deadline for conversion, giving startups flexibility in managing their fundraising and financial planning. Investors must wait for a trigger event (such as a new equity round) for their SAFE to convert into shares.

4. Investor Risk & Return

• Convertible Note: Investors in convertible notes have greater protection compared to SAFE holders. Because it is structured as debt, the startup is contractually obligated to repay the investor if conversion does not occur. This reduces the investor’s risk, as they have a potential exit strategy through repayment.
• SAFE: SAFE investors take on more risk because there is no repayment obligation and no guaranteed return. If the startup fails before a triggering event (such as a funding round or acquisition), SAFE investors may end up with nothing. While SAFEs offer upside potential when the company grows, they provide less security than convertible notes.

5. Complexity and Legal Considerations

• Convertible Note: Due to their loan-like nature, convertible notes require formal legal structuring, including an interest rate, repayment terms, and maturity date. They may also involve negotiations around discount rates, valuation caps, and extension terms, making them more complex to draft and execute.
• SAFE: SAFEs are simpler and faster to execute because they do not involve debt terms or repayment clauses. They require less legal documentation and are designed to be a founder-friendly investment vehicle, minimizing administrative and legal burdens for startups.

6. Startup Cash Flow Impact

• Convertible Note: Since convertible notes can require repayment if not converted, they can create a potential liability for the startup. If the company does not secure new funding or reach a conversion event, it might have to repay investors, which could strain cash flow.
• SAFE: SAFEs do not have repayment obligations, making them more cash-flow friendly for startups. Since investors only receive equity at a future event (without the expectation of repayment), startups can focus on growth without worrying about looming financial obligations.

Pros and Cons of Convertible Notes and SAFE Agreements

Pros of Convertible Notes

• Investor protection through debt structure – Convertible notes act as a loan until they convert into equity, giving investors the legal right to demand repayment if conversion doesn’t happen.
• Accrues interest to increase investment value – The interest accumulated on the note increases the total amount converted into equity, giving investors a larger ownership stake when the company raises a priced round.
• Clear repayment timeline with maturity date – Convertible notes include a maturity date, ensuring that investors will either be repaid or receive equity within a set timeframe.
• Stronger negotiation power for investors – Investors have more leverage to negotiate terms such as valuation caps, conversion discounts, and repayment rights, giving them greater security.
• Better for startups planning near-term fundraising – If a startup expects to raise a priced equity round soon, convertible notes serve as a structured way to bridge the funding gap while setting clear expectations for conversion.

Cons of Convertible Notes

• Creates debt obligations for the startup – Until the note converts, it appears as a liability on the startup’s balance sheet, which can make future fundraising more challenging.
• Potential for financial strain due to repayment clause – If the startup does not reach a qualifying event for conversion, investors may demand repayment, which can put significant financial pressure on the company.
• Legal complexity increases costs – Convertible notes require more legal structuring, including setting interest rates, maturity dates, and repayment terms, leading to higher legal and administrative expenses.
• May require renegotiation if startup doesn’t raise a new round – If the startup doesn’t secure the next round of funding before the maturity date, the terms may need to be renegotiated with investors, causing delays and uncertainty.
• Uncertain valuation until conversion – Investors don’t know their exact ownership percentage until the note converts, which can create uncertainty if the startup’s valuation changes significantly.

 Pros of SAFE Agreements

• Founder-friendly with no repayment obligation – Unlike convertible notes, SAFEs are not structured as debt, meaning startups are not legally required to repay the investment, even if conversion never happens.
• No interest accrual keeps equity dilution lower – Since SAFEs do not accumulate interest, startups avoid the additional dilution that comes with interest-bearing convertible notes.
• No maturity date gives startups flexibility – There is no deadline for conversion, allowing startups to delay issuing equity until a trigger event occurs, such as a new funding round.
• Simple and cost-effective to implement – SAFEs require minimal legal paperwork and are easier to execute compared to convertible notes, reducing legal fees and administrative burdens.
• Encourages investor-startup alignment – Investors receive future equity rather than a repayment obligation, ensuring their interests are tied to the long-term success of the startup.

Cons of SAFE Agreements

• Riskier for investors due to lack of repayment option – Since there is no guarantee of conversion or repayment, investors risk losing their entire investment if the startup fails.
• No fixed timeline for conversion – Investors have no control over when their SAFE converts into equity, as it depends on the startup raising a future financing round.
• More favorable to startups, making investors hesitant – Many investors prefer convertible notes because they offer more protections, making SAFEs a harder sell for some venture capitalists.
• Dilution risk due to uncapped conversion – If a SAFE does not include a valuation cap, investors may end up with significantly less equity than expected when it eventually converts.
• Uncertain ownership stake until a priced round – Since the conversion terms are tied to future funding events, investors do not know exactly how much ownership they will receive when they invest.

Convertible Note vs. SAFE: Which is Right for the Startup? Considerations

No single answer fits every situation when choosing between a Convertible Note vs. SAFE. The optimal choice hinges on specific circumstances, the company’s stage, and relationships with investors. Here are some questions founders should consider:

• Funding Speed: How quickly is the funding needed? SAFEs are generally faster to negotiate and close than a Convertible Note. The SAFE excels in speed.
• Debt Comfort Level: What is the startup’s tolerance for taking on debt? If founders are averse to debt, the SAFE might be a more suitable option than a Convertible Note.
• Investor Preferences: What do potential investors prefer? Engaging in conversations with investors helps understand their preferences regarding Convertible Note vs. SAFE structures. Some may prefer the security features of a Convertible Note (interest, maturity date), while others are comfortable with the simplicity of a SAFE. Understanding the investor view on Convertible Note vs. SAFE is vital.
• Long-Term Strategy: How might each instrument (Convertible Note vs. SAFE) affect future fundraising efforts? Consider the long-term cap table implications.

Seeking advice from legal and financial professionals is crucial. They can assist in evaluating the terms of a Convertible Note vs. SAFE and guide the decision-making process for the company’s specific needs. Relying solely on general information isn’t sufficient. Professional advice on Convertible Note vs. SAFE is recommended.

Conclusion

Both Convertible Notes and SAFE agreements serve as effective fundraising tools for startups. The choice between the two depends on factors such as investment structure, risk tolerance, and cash flow considerations. Convertible Notes offer structured investments with debt protection, while SAFE agreements provide a simple, flexible, and founder-friendly approach. By understanding the key differences, startups can make informed decisions that align with their financial strategy and growth objectives.

Did you find this Legitt article worthwhile? More engaging blogs about smart contracts on the blockchain, contract management software and electronic signatures can be found in the Legitt Blogs section. You may also contact Legitt to hire the best contract lifecycle management services and solutions.